Table 4. Texture properties for powdered microcapsules of tomato extracts-added Appenzeller cheeses during ripening at 14℃ for 6 mon

Ripening period (mon) Concentration1) (% w/w) Texture description
Hardness (N2) Cohesiveness (J3) Gumminess (N) Springiness (m×10−3) Chewiness (J×10−3)
0 Control2) 10.99±0.45J3) 0.69±0.01BCDEF 7.57±0.32F 0.74±0.11A 5.64±0.73H
1 11.64±1.14IJ 0.72±0.02ABCD 8.48±0.75F 0.82±0.13A 7.02±3.31H
2 12.16±1.15IJ 0.73±0.03ABCD 9.36±0.57F 0.83±0.12A 7.76±1.44H
3 12.28±1.05IJ 0.75±0.04AB 9.06±0.69F 0.85±0.13A 7.26±1.44H
4 12.46±1.76IJ 0.76±0.04A 9.27±1.23F 0.83±0.14A 7.73±1.65H
1 Control 12.19±1.56IJ 0.74±0.02ABC 8.96±1.13F 0.83±0.15A 7.42±1.73H
1 13.39±0.97IJ 0.70±0.03ABCDEF 9.38±0.79F 0.84±0.11A 7.20±1.42H
2 13.16±0.91IJ 0.72±0.01ABCD 9.54±0.69F 0.83±0.15A 7.91±1.12H
3 13.60±0.71IJ 0.73±0.02ABCD 9.93±0.64F 0.83±0.14A 8.27±1.31H
4 13.88±0.88IJ 0.75±0.03AB 10.45±0.93EF 0.82±0.14A 8.66±0.88FGH
2 Control 14.08±1.64IJ 0.69±0.02BCDEF 9.76±1.35F 0.71±0.02A 8.58±3.52FGH
1 14.27±2.32IJ 0.67±0.02DEFG 9.98±1.18F 0.78±0.10A 7.61±2.34H
2 14.40±0.38IJ 0.68±0.01CDEFG 10.02±0.43F 0.82±0.01A 8.11±1.36H
3 14.44±0.33IJ 0.71±0.02ABCDE 10.18±0.22F 0.76±0.10A 8.37±0.72GH
4 14.66±1.46I 0.68±0.04CDEFG 10.61±1.26EF 0.78±0.11A 8.70±0.88EFGH
3 Control 22.56±2.64H 0.68±0.03CDEFG 14.83±1.17DE 0.77±0.13A 12.42±1.63DEFG
1 24.70±1.85GH 0.68±0.02CDEFG 15.74±1.61CD 0.77±0.02A 12.53±1.03DEF
2 25.36±1.05FGH 0.64±0.02FGHI 16.82±1.93ABCD 0.81±0.13A 13.2±4.08BCD
3 26.46±1.83EFG 0.64±0.02FGHI 17.15±0.38ABCD 0.75±0.09A 13.15±0.59BCD
4 27.49±1.98EFG 0.64±0.05FGHI 17.21±0.94ABCD 0.76±0.10A 13.01±1.88CD
4 Control 24.84±3.09GH 0.67±0.02DEFG 16.56±0.82BCD 0.76±0.01A 12.82±2.11CDE
1 26.38±2.90EFG 0.64±0.04FGHI 17.15±1.17ABCD 0.77±0.08A 13.66±2.26BCD
2 26.91±2.23EFG 0.67±0.02DEFG 17.36±1.09ABCD 0.73±0.17A 13.20±1.39BCD
3 28.79±2.17DEF 0.65±0.03EFGH 18.02±0.77ABCD 0.74±0.08A 13.23±1.23BCD
4 29.07±2.96DE 0.64±0.03FGHI 18.09±1.81ABCD 0.75±0.14A 13.27±1.97BCD
5 Control 27.31±2.27EFG 0.59±0.01HIJ 17.98±4.62ABCD 0.75±0.15A 15.62±1.03ABCD
1 29.72±2.03DE 0.62±0.05GHI 18.28±1.52ABCD 0.76±0.02A 16.95±1.10ABC
2 31.52±4.32CD 0.59±0.05HIJ 18.72±1.34ABCD 0.71±0.17A 18.88±4.54A
3 33.41±3.08bBC 0.58±0.09IJ 19.11±1.89ABCD 0.73±0.18A 18.85±6.00A
4 34.98±3.82ABC 0.51±0.03KL 20.26±0.53AB 0.75±0.14A 18.81±0.63A
6 Control 33.79±3.43ABC 0.59±0.05HIJ 18.17±1.77ABCD 0.74±1.29A 17.17±2.57AB
1 35.08±4.13ABC 0.54±0.05JK 19.36±6.25ABC 0.74±0.13A 18.91±4.36A
2 36.42±2.61AB 0.46±0.02L 19.73±3.32ABC 0.70±0.21A 19.03±2.39A
3 37.14±1.75A 0.48±0.05KL 20.34±2.01AB 0.72±0.16A 19.37±3.39A
4 37.32±0.68A 0.48±0.09KL 21.08±12.24A 0.74±0.33A 19.63±5.83A