Table 5. Changes in color for powdered microcapsules of tomato extracts-added Appenzeller cheeses during ripening at 14℃ for 6 mon

Concentration1) (%, w/w) Colour value
L (lightness) a (redness) b (yellowness)
0 mon
Control2) 79.05±1.48AB3) 3.49±0.13A 11.11±0.58K
1 76.97±0.82CDEFGH 2.24±0.18BCDE 12.16±0.33JK
2 77.15±0.49CDEFG 2.28±0.21BCDE 12.18±0.69JK
3 77.42±0.87BCDEF 2.37±0.27B 12.21±0.81JK
4 79.37±0.75A 1.74±0.24E 12.30±1.08J
1 mon
Control 78.65±1.56ABC 3.67±0.11A 12.43±0.23IJ
1 76.95±0.48CDEFGH 2.26±0.47BCDE 12.18±0.94JK
2 76.86±0.46DEFGH 2.28±0.44BCDE 13.77±0.54DEFG
3 76.42±0.52DEFGHI 2.37±0.22B 14.48±0.32CDEF
4 75.70±0.53FGHIJ 1.77±0.15DE 14.50±0.65CDEF
2 mon
Control 78.16±1.13ABCD 3.73±0.10A 12.57±0.18HIJ
1 74.99±0.87IJKL 2.29±0.52BCD 12.97±0.76GHIJ
2 74.86±1.03IJKL 2.34±0.36BC 14.51±0.22CDEF
3 75.77±0.92EFGHIJ 2.50±0.24B 14.59±0.71CDEF
4 74.55±0.57JKL 1.80±0.34CDE 14.64±0.79CDEF
3 mon
Control 77.88±0.90ABCD 3.69±0.14A 12.62±0.27GHIJ
1 75.35±0.75HIJ 2.57±0.31B 13.48±0.68FGHI
2 75.83±0.86EFGHIJ 2.43±0.41B 14.79±1.19BCDE
3 75.29±1.19HIJK 2.48±0.34B 14.84±0.25ABCD
4 75.31±1.26HIJ 2.07±0.13BCDE 15.90±0.83AB
4 mon
Control 77.50±0.94BCDE 3.70±0.32A 12.26±0.33JK
1 73.53±1.08KL 2.55±0.35B 13.63±0.81EFGH
2 74.35±1.04JKL 2.44±0.27B 15.05±0.68ABC
3 73.43±1.07L 2.49±0.48B 15.10±0.47ABC
4 74.30±0.93JKL 2.25±0.41BCDE 15.91±0.32AB
5 mon
Control 75.75±0.98EFGHIJ 3.77±0.31A 12.82±0.33GHIJ
1 75.80±1.51EFGHIJ 2.59±0.35B 14.98±0.81ABC
2 74.35±1.04JKL 2.47±0.35B 15.10±0.55ABC
3 73.43±1.06L 2.50±0.24B 15.21±0.54ABC
4 73.50±1.29L 2.33±0.84BC 15.97±1.13A
6 mon
Control 74.26±1.66JKL 3.78±0.24A 12.88±0.45GHIJ
1 74.45±1.87JKL 2.60±0.19B 15.21±0.85ABC
2 74.24±1.46JKL 2.57±0.25B 15.31±0.58ABC
3 74.52±1.63JKL 2.53±0.25B 15.36±1.32ABC
4 74.89±0.99JKL 2.37±0.41B 16.00±1.38A