Table 3. Effects of different antioxidants on color values of fresh beef patties at frozen storage

Storage month Con BHT AA CE SEM
Lightness (CIE L*) 0 41.07Aa 41.25Aa 41.51Aa 40.63Aa 1.98
2 39.70Aa 40.38Aa 39.78Aa 40.28Aa 2.15
4 39.27Aa 41.07Aa 40.54Aa 40.50Aa 1.66
6 39.07Aa 40.65Aa 40.13Aa 38.98Aa 1.14
SEM 1.64 1.44 1.80 2.06
Redness (CIE a*) 0 22.13Aa 23.84Aa 23.13Aa 20.98Aa 0.73
2 21.98Aa 23.13ABa 20.40ABa 22.26Aa 1.17
4 12.56Bb 19.78BCa 18.47Ba 18.44Ba 1.01
6 11.42Bb 17.90Ca 18.56Ba 17.65Ba 0.78
SEM 1.07 1.04 0.84 0.74
Yellowness (CIE b*) 0 15.37Aa 16.22Aa 16.19Aa 15.82Aa 0.75
2 19.22Aa 19.49Aa 19.61Aa 20.76Aa 5.43
4 11.66Aa 13.39Aa 12.69Aa 13.34Aa 0.77
6 11.50Ab 12.43Aab 12.65Aab 12.98Aa 0.38
SEM 1.90 1.67 1.88 1.88
Chroma (C*) 0 26.94Aa 28.85Aa 28.24Aa 26.29Aa 0.97
2 23.58Aa 24.95Ba 22.19Ba 24.54ABa 1.73
4 17.19Bb 23.90Ba 22.45Ba 22.79ABa 1.03
6 16.21Bb 21.82Ba 22.22Ba 21.39Ba 0.75
SEM 1.27 1.06 0.98 1.18
Hue angel (h°) 0 34.83ABa 34.18Aa 34.91Aa 36.92Aa 0.86
2 25.92Ba 26.80Aa 27.15Aa 28.27Aa 7.46
4 43.09Aa 34.14Ab 34.67Ab 35.82Ab 1.86
6 45.36Aa 34.76Ab 34.56Ab 36.35Ab 1.51
SEM 2.90 2.29 3.27 3.23
Mean values in the same row with different letters presented significant differences (p<0.05).
Mean values in the same column with different letters presented significant differences (p<0.05).
Con, control; BHT, added 0.02% butylated hydroxytoluene; AA, added 0.05% ascrobic acid; CE, added 0.1% clove extract.