Table 1. Aroma components of mealworms by different cooking methods

Aroma components No. RI1) Cas # Relative peak area (mean±SD)2) ID
Raw Steaming Roasting Frying
Pyrazines
 2,6-Dimethyl-pyrazine 1 910 108-50-9 NDb3) NDb NDb 0.283±0.029a MS/RI4)
 2,5-Dimethyl-pyrazine 2 911 123-32-0 NDb NDb 0.675±0.027a NDb MS/RI
 2-Ethyl-5-methyl-pyrazine 3 1,001 13360-64-0 NDb NDb 0.196±0.032a NDb MS/RI
 2,3,5-Trimethyl-pyrazine 4 1,002 14667-55-1 NDc NDc 0.157±0.015b 0.238±0.008a MS/RI
 Sum of pyrazines 05) (0%)6) 0 (0%) 1.028 (6.07%) 0.521 (3.44%)
Pyrrolidines
 1-Butyl-pyrrolidine 5 895 767-10-2 NDc NDc 0.220±0.019b 0.296±0.042a MS
 1-(2-Methyl-1-butenyl)-pyrrolidine 6 1,082 14091-87-3 NDb NDb NDb 1.083±0.142a MS/RI
 1-(1-Pentenyl)-pyrrolidine 7 1,128 13937-90-1 NDb NDb NDb 0.071±0.012a MS
 Sum of pyrrolidines 0 0 0.220 (1.30%) 1.450 (9.57%)
Aldehydes
 Benzaldehyde 8 957 100-52-7 NDb 0.012±0.001b 0.292±0.021a NDb MS/RI
 2-Phenylacetaldehyde 9 1,041 122-78-1 0.075±0.015b 0.090±0.001b 0.125±0.012a NDc MS/RI
 4-Methyl-benzaldehyde 10 1,078 104-87-0 5.496±0.754b 6.788±0.496a 6.350±0.081ab 4.289±0.805c MS/RI
 Sum of aldehydes 5.571 (37.14%) 6.890 (39.37%) 6.767 (39.93%) 4.289 (28.28%)
Ketones
 Heptan-2-one 11 892 110-43-0 NDc NDc 0.077±0.013b 0.188±0.021a MS/RI
 Methylsulfonylmethane 12 923 67-71-0 0.033±0.005bc 0.012±0.001c 0.255±0.028a 0.051±0.001b MS/RI
 4-Methylheptan-2-one 13 939 6137-06-0 0.071±0.003a 0.019±0.003a NDb NDb MS/RI
 3,5-Dihydroxy-6-methyl-2,3-dihydropyran-4-one 14 1,139 28564-83-2 NDb 0.069±0.010a NDb NDb MS/RI
 1-(4-Acetylphenyl)-ethanone 15 1,431 1009-61-6 0.985±0.172a 0.770±0.152a 0.510±0.059b 0.303±0.058b MS/RI
 2,6-Ditert-butylcyclohexa-2,5-diene-1,4-dione 16 1,466 719-22-2 0.181±0.028b 0.237±0.045a NDc NDc MS/RI
 Sum of ketones 1.270 (8.11%) 1.107 (6.32%) 0.842 (4.97%) 0.542 (3.57%)
Alcohols
 Pentan-1-ol 17 759 71-41-0 NDb NDb NDb 0.193±0.019a MS/RI
 2-Butoxyethanol 18 907 111-76-2 0.010±0.002a NDb NDb NDb MS/RI
 Oct-1-en-3-ol 19 980 3391-86-4 NDb NDb 0.102±0.015a NDb MS/RI
 2,4-Bis(1,1-dimethylethyl)-phenol 20 1,511 96-76-4 0.580±0.109a 0.487±0.093a 0.153±0.024b 0.100±0.017b MS/RI
 Cadin-4-en-10-ol 21 1,655 481-34-5 0.025±0.005a NDb 0.024±0.003a NDb MS/RI
 Sum of alcohols 0.615 (4.10%) 0.487 (2.78%) 0.279 (1.65%) 0.293 (1.93%)
Esters & acid
 Bis(2-methylpropyl)-hexanedioate 22 1,684 141-04-8 0.027±0.004a NDb NDb NDb MS/RI
 Hexadecanoic acid 23 1,947 57-10-3 0.013±0.002b 0.017±0.003b 0.023±0.002a NDc MS/RI
 Dibutly-benzene-1,2-dicarboxylate 24 1,960 84-74-2 0.041±0.011a 0.015±0.002b 0.019±0.002b NDc MS/RI
 Sum of esters & acid 0.081 (0.55%) 0.032 (0.18%) 0.042 (0.25%) 0 (0%)
Hydrocarbons
 Octane 25 797 111-65-9 0.263±0.046c 0.341±0.029c 0.481±0.081b 0.602±0.079a MS/RI
 Oct-2-ene 26 805 111-67-1 NDb NDb NDb 0.063±0.009a MS/RI
 2,4-Dimethyl-hept-1-ene 27 838 19549-87-2 0.948±0.164b 1.073±0.076ab 1.301±0.223a 1.175±0.200ab MS/RI
 2,3-Dimethyl-heptane 28 852 3074-71-3 0.016±0.003a NDb NDb NDb MS/RI
 Ethyl-benzene 29 857 100-41-4 0.015±0.001a NDb NDb NDb MS/RI
 4-Methyl-octane 30 861 2216-34-4 0.110±0.013b 0.080±0.005b 0.168±0.022a 0.103±0.018b MS/RI
 1,4-Xylene 31 865 106-42-3 0.034±0.004b 0.034±0.005b 0.037±0.004b 0.062±0.010a MS/RI
 2,4,6-Trimethyl-heptane 32 871 2613-61-8 NDb 0.014±0.000a NDb NDb MS/RI
 Nonane 33 899 111-84-2 0.018±0.001b 0.022±0.002a NDc NDc MS/RI
 4-Ethyl-octane 34 954 15869-86-0 0.012±0.001b 0.014±0.001a NDc NDc MS/RI
 4-Methyl-nonane 35 961 17301-94-9 0.086±0.008a 0.102±0.006a NDb 0.099±0.016a MS/RI
 3-Methyl-nonane 36 970 5911-04-6 0.038±0.006b 0.045±0.005a NDc NDc MS/RI
 2,2,4,6,6-Pentamethyl-heptane 37 987 13475-82-6 0.097±0.014a 0.114±0.020a 0.114±0.021a NDb MS/RI
 Decane 38 999 124-18-5 2.109±0.331b 2.547±0.183ab 2.563±0.161ab 2.839±0.543a MS/RI
 2,6-Dimethyl-nonane 39 1,012 17302-28-2 0.649±0.084a 0.698±0.050a 0.772±0.059a 0.772±0.098a MS/RI
 2,2,7,7-Tetramethyl-octane 40 1,023 1071-31-4 0.116±0.013a 0.127±0.014a NDb NDb MS/RI
 5-Ethyl-2,2,3-trimethyl-heptane 41 1,029 62199-06-8 0.147±0.010a 0.070±0.005b NDc NDc MS
 2,4-Dimethyl-dodecane 42 1,168 6117-99-3 NDb 0.051±0.001a NDb NDb MS/RI
 Dodecane 43 1,197 112-40-3 2.083±0.333b 2.678±0.152a 1.951±0.032b 1.790±0.112b MS/RI
 4,8-Dimethyl-undecane 44 1,212 17301-33-6 0.079±0.015b 0.097±0.004a NDc NDc MS/RI
 2,6,11-Trimethyl-dodecane 45 1,279 31295-56-4 NDb NDb NDb 0.257±0.040a MS/RI
 Tetradecane 46 1,398 629-59-4 0.697±0.030a 0.879±0.175a 0.377±0.066b 0.306±0.058b MS/RI
 Sum of hydrocarbons 7.517 (50.11%) 9.022 (51.34%) 7.764 (45.83%) 8.068 (53.20%)
Retention indices were determined using n-paraffins C7–C22 as external references.
Average of each peak area compared to that of the internal standard (n=3)±SD.
There are significant differences (p<0.05) among samples according to heating methods by using Duncan’s multiple comparison test between the samples having different letter in low.
MS, mass spectrum and retention index were consistent with those of an authentic compound; RI, mass spectrum and retention index were consistent with that of Wiley 7n and NIST17 mass spectrum database or manual interpretation (tentative identification).
Sum of each peak area compared to that of the internal standard (n=3).
Sum and their relative percentages of each peak areas according to chemical groups.
ND, not detected.