Table 3. pH and color in semi-dried restructured jerky prepared with loquat leaf extract (LE) and ascorbic acid (AA) during storage
Treatment | Storage (d) |
1 | 20 | 45 | 90 | 135 | 180 |
pH |
Control | 6.15±0.01Aa | 6.12±0.01Ab | 6.12±0.01Ab | 6.11±0.01Abc | 6.11±0.01Ac | 6.10±0.01Ac |
AA | 6.06±0.01Da | 6.06±0.01ca | 6.06±0.01Ba | 6.06±0.01Ba | 6.06±0.01Ba | 6.01±0.01Db |
LE 0.15 | 6.09±0.01Ba | 6.07±0.01BCb | 6.07±0.01Bb | 6.06±0.01Bc | 6.06±0.01Bc | 6.05±0.01Bc |
LE 0.15-AA | 6.05±0.01Ea | 6.04±0.01Db | 6.04±0.01Cb | 6.02±0.01Cc | 6.00±0.01Dd | 6.00±0.01Ee |
LE 0.3 | 6.08±0.01Ca | 6.08±0.01Ba | 6.06±0.01Bb | 6.06±0.01Bb | 6.05±0.01Bc | 6.03±0.01Cd |
LE 0.3-AA | 6.04±0.01Fa | 6.03±0.01Db | 6.02±0.01Dc | 6.02±0.01Cc | 6.02±0.01Cc | 5.99±0.01Ed |
CIE L* |
Control | 48.72±0.38ABe | 50.31±0.19Ad | 50.65±0.18Ad | 51.57±0.18Ac | 53.22±0.21Ab | 54.18±0.17Aa |
AA | 49.07±0.19Ac | 49.13±0.19Bc | 50.38±0.08Ab | 50.58±0.30Bb | 50.93±0.13Bb | 51.68±0.38Ba |
LE 0.15 | 47.67±0.25CDb | 48.03±0.22Cb | 49.33±0.11Cc | 49.33±0.15Cc | 50.10±0.09Cb | 51.68±0.38Ba |
LE 0.15-AA | 48.14±0.08BCc | 48.23±0.09Cc | 49.29±0.14Bb | 49.66±0.31Cb | 50.34±0.18Ca | 50.46±0.30Ca |
LE 0.3 | 46.43±0.19Ec | 46.82±0.13Dc | 46.84±0.15Dc | 47.96±0.20Db | 48.02±0.24Db | 48.90±0.16Da |
LE 0.3-AA | 47.13±0.25DEb | 47.33±0.28Db | 47.56±0.12Eb | 47.69±0.22Db | 47.48±0.09Eb | 48.30±0.18Da |
CIE a* |
Control | 14.63±0.12Ba | 14.35±0.18Aa | 13.80±0.07Bb | 12.92±0.22Bc | 12.48±0.15Bc | 11.65±0.27Cd |
AA | 16.62±0.33Aa | 16.20±0.19Bab | 16.02±0.19Ab | 15.46±0.07Ac | 14.73±0.11Ad | 14.38±0.14Ad |
LE 0.15 | 11.91±0.33Ca | 11.56±0.32Dab | 11.31±0.18Dabc | 11.10±0.11Cbc | 10.74±0.07Cc | 9.52±0.05Dd |
LE 0.15-AA | 14.25±0.14Ba | 13.33±0.25Cb | 13.33±0.13Cb | 12.79±0.01Bc | 12.75±0.12Bc | 12.56±0.17Bc |
LE 0.3 | 9.76±0.05Ea | 9.73±0.09Fa | 9.53±0.11Fa | 9.03±0.22Eab | 8.81±0.43Db | 8.73±0.27Eb |
LE 0.3-AA | 10.55±0.12D | 10.54±0.04E | 10.43±0.10E | 10.40±0.10D | 10.21±0.05C | 10.04±0.38D |
CIE b* |
Control | 12.09±0.03Fe | 14.56±0.24Ed | 15.28±0.24Ed | 16.17±0.32Ec | 17.36±0.32Db | 18.41±0.23Da |
AA | 14.63±0.36Ec | 14.83±0.14Ec | 15.80±0.25Eb | 15.95±0.16Eb | 16.64±0.29Da | 17.05±0.12Ea |
LE 0.15 | 15.77±0.43Dd | 16.32±0.15Dcd | 16.99±0.05Dbc | 17.27±0.11Db | 18.66±0.42Ca | 19.09±0.09Ca |
LE 0.15-AA | 17.57±0.15Cb | 17.79±0.19Cb | 18.00±0.19Cb | 18.22±0.23Cb | 19.31±0.40Ca | 19.62±0.14Ca |
LE 0.3 | 19.76±0.17Bc | 19.90±0.11Bc | 20.01±0.07Bc | 20.30±0.24Bbc | 20.84±0.33Bab | 20.95±0.16Ba |
LE 0.3-AA | 21.83±0.22A | 21.97±0.18A | 22.10±0.18A | 22.23±0.36A | 22.63±0.35A | 22.67±0.30A |
p-value | Storage | LE | AA | Storage×LE | Storage×AA | LE×AA | Storage×LE×AA |
pH | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** |
CIE L* | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** | * |
CIE a* | *** | *** | *** | *** | ** | *** | NS |
CIE b* | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** |
All values are mean±SE of three replicates.
Control, no antioxidant; AA, added 0.05% ascorbic acid; LE 0.15, added 0.15 loquat leaf extract; LE 0.15-AA, added 0.15% loquat leaf extract and 0.05% ascorbic acid; LE 0.3, added 0.3% loquat leaf extract; LE0.3-AA, added 0.3% loquat leaf extract and 0.05% ascorbic acid.
Means sharing different letters in the same column are significantly different.
Means sharing different letters in the same row are significantly different.
p<0.05
p<0.01
p<0.001.
NS, no significance.