Table 2. Weight change ratio and protein solubility of single layer gelatin films with different concentrations of mustard or oregano essential oils at 4°C in water

Variable Time Mustard essential oil (%) Oregano essential oil (%)
0 20 40 60 80 0 10 20 30 40
Weigh change ratio 1 day 5.50±0.31a 4.48±0.55b 4.01±0.63bc 3.26±0.26cd 3.11±0.28d 5.50±0.32a 4.21±0.59b 3.50±0.83bc 3.11±0.40c 2.95±0.24c
2 day 5.40±0.21a 4.39±0.38b 4.00±0.20b 3.22±0.58c 3.05±0.41c 5.40±0.21a 4.10±0.16ab 2.96±0.26b 3.13±0.21b 2.86±0.11b
3 day 5.39±0.45a 4.32±0.35b 3.96±0.31b 3.23±0.34c 3.12±0.62c 5.39±0.45a 4.10±0.80b 2.90±0.24c 3.10±0.14c 2.80±0.45c
4 day 5.23±0.23a 4.12±0.23b 3.83±0.35b 3.12±0.20c 3.10±0.42c 5.23±0.23a 3.91±0.12ab 2.69±0.63b 2.85±0.29b 2.71±0.13b
p-value Time 0.539 0.550
Essential oil 0.000 0.000
Time×Essential oil 1.000 1.000
Protein solubility (mg/mL) 1 day 0.34±0.01dD 2.14±0.01cC 3.02±0.02bC 3.23±0.03aC 3.39±0.06aC 0.34±0.01eD 1.24±0.02dD 1.98±0.04cD 3.02±0.16bB 3.23±0.04aC
2 day 0.41±0.01dC 2.56±0.07cB 3.23±0.09bB 3.31±0.08abC 3.43±0.06aC 0.41±0.01dC 1.64±0.06cC 2.44±0.08bB 3.23±0.09aA 3.31±0.08aC
3 day 0.43±0.08eB 2.84±0.09dA 3.31±0.09cB 3.43±0.06bB 3.57±0.02aB 0.43±0.08eB 1.91±0.04dB 2.33±0.02cC 3.31±0.18bA 3.43±0.06aB
4 day 0.46±0.01dA 2.97±0.08cA 3.55±0.08bA 3.66±0.07abA 3.72±0.08aA 0.46±0.01eA 2.04±0.03dA 2.69±0.05cA 3.33±0.09bA 3.60±0.06aA
p-value Time 0.000 0.000
Essential oil 0.000 0.000
Time×Essential oil 0.000 0.000
For each essential oil, capital letters in each column represent significant differences (p<0.05).
For each essential oil, lowercase letters in each row represent significant differences (p<0.05).